Call for freedom instead of a caliphate: Why Iran demonstrations are so different


While so-called caliphate demonstrations are often characterized by aggression, exiled Iranians in Germany show a different picture. FOCUS online chief correspondent Ulrich Reitz explains the historical and cultural reasons – and why he considers the Greens’ stance to be a mistake.

Under the motto “Freedom for Iran,” thousands of people demonstrated against the mullahs’ regime in Germany over the weekend. Israeli, American and Iranian flags flew side by side – without violence, without burning flags.

For FOCUS online chief correspondent Ulrich Reitz, this is no coincidence, but rather an expression of a fundamental difference.

When asked why Iranian demonstrations are so different from so-called caliphate demonstrations, which are often characterized by aggression and violence, Reitz answers unequivocally: “Persians are not Arabs.”

Reitz: Democracy in Iran is conceivable

He points to Persia’s millennia-old history and emphasizes that Iran was only Islamized in the seventh century. The current regime is the result of a revolution in 1979 that hijacked an ancient people.

At the same time, there is “a strong, educated middle class” in Iran and the hope “that a population is capable of building a democracy or something that comes very close to a democracy.”

That’s why a caliphate demonstration by Palestinians is socio-politically “the complete opposite of a liberation demonstration by Iranians who have found a new home here. It is the complete opposite.”

There are “really qualified international lawyers” such as those from the University of Bonn, who the attacks considered justifiable under the aspect of self-defense and a possible humanitarian intervention.

At the same time, he reminds us of the internal brutality of the regime: “Khamenei’s henchmen shot down over 30,000 demonstrators and killed them in their torture chambers.”

Reitz: Greens with fatal misjudgment for 47 years

Reitz is particularly harsh on the Greens. He speaks of “a line that leads from a mistake from 1979 to Annalena Baerbock.”

To illustrate this, he quotes former Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer from 1979: The Islamic revolution “is also and especially directed against the penetration of the consumerist atheism of Western industrial societies.”

Many leftists at the time saw Ayatollah Khomeini as a liberator and not a “clerical fascist.” This misjudgment continues to have an impact today.

For Reitz, the difference can also be seen on German streets: for the Iranian exiles it is a freedom movement against an oppressive regime and for the Palestinians it is demonstrations with the opposite thrust.

  • Related Posts

    Tens of thousands of people evacuated: floods in Hawaii

    Instead of the turquoise blue sea, brown tides currently dominate the image of Hawaii. Mass water pushes through streets and residential areas. Many people had to leave their homes hastily.…

    Six “Tatort” editions may not be repeated

    Despite allegations against Christian Ulmen, ARD is keeping the “Tatort” episodes with him available in the media library for the time being, and a repeat on TV cannot be ruled…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Tens of thousands of people evacuated: floods in Hawaii

    Tens of thousands of people evacuated: floods in Hawaii

    Six “Tatort” editions may not be repeated

    Six “Tatort” editions may not be repeated

    “Mechanism unclear”: What you need to know about paracetamol

    “Mechanism unclear”: What you need to know about paracetamol

    That’s how dependent Rhineland-Palatinate is on the richest country in the world

    That’s how dependent Rhineland-Palatinate is on the richest country in the world

    “The Porsche customer stays, the Opel customer buys a Chinese”

    “The Porsche customer stays, the Opel customer buys a Chinese”

    “24 minutes is optimal”: specially composed music can noticeably reduce anxiety

    “24 minutes is optimal”: specially composed music can noticeably reduce anxiety